The Spiel of Approval Award
The Spiel of Approval Award was created to recognize and celebrate games that:
- encourage thoughtful and strategic play
- have clear and comprehensive rules
- are fun because they make you think
- are built to last
- grow more rewarding the more times you play
- are original in some aspect
Games that win the Spiel of Approval award tend to:
- appeal to more experienced players but are not exclusively "gamers" games
- have multiple paths to victory
- create lasting moments or memories
Publishers/games that receive the award are licensed to use the Spiel of Approval Award logo with that product - on the package, in print, and associated media for the edition of the game that was submitted/reviewed. We will will have rolls of labels/stickers with the Spiel of Approval award logo available. Contact Stephen for details.
Games that win The Spiel of Approval promote thoughtful fun and play. These games help players discover and enjoy the fun you can have by using your brain.
Each year, we use our experience and expertise to guide you through the thousands of games available to a select few noteworthy titles you might enjoy too.
A few of these winners will also merit the additional honor as a Keeper
Being selected as a Keeper is a special honor above and beyond the Spiel of Approval. These are games we think will stand any test of time. They will remain engaging no matter how many games and how many years pass by. Keepers are a rare breed and deserve special recognition for the lasting fun they create. If you enjoy games that make you think, Keepers are games we think you should definitely make room for on your shelf!
Our Review Philosophy
Thousands of new game titles are published every year. There is no way we can be comprehensive and cover every game that hits the market. That is not our goal.
Our guiding philosophy is to point players toward games we genuinely enjoy and think others might as well. We publish 30 game reviews each season on The Spiel.
We want a game being selected for The Spiel of Approval to mean something. For every game that makes the grade, there may be ten or twenty others that did not make the cut.
Fun is the ultimate test. We realize and appreciate that fun comes in many forms from the silly frantic fun of kids or party games (Major Fun!) to the brain burning challenges of heavier strategy games and everything in between. If we think a game is worth of a Spiel of Approval or a Major Fun award, we think it’s fun and MOST IMPORTANTLY, we’ll tell you why!
It’s not enough for us to say we like a game and you should too. We want you to know basic information about the game (concept, components, mechanics). We also want you to know what sets the game apart from others and then and only then can we give you a sense of why we enjoy the game and what kinds of players might enjoy it as well. From there, we trust you can make your own informed decision about whether this is a game that might speak to you.
We don’t like every game we play. But we do like every game we review
This doesn’t mean the games we cover are perfect. Far from it. We often point out problems and issues in games we review. That said, if a game is reviewed on The Spiel, we feel whatever its flaws might be, there’s way more fun than frustration waiting for you in the box. We're willing to back that up with our Spiel of Approval!
Publishers are welcome to submit games for consideration for The Spiel of Approval Award.
There are two important items of note to be aware of before submitting a game:
1. We play hundreds of new games each year.
Our to-be-played pile is always a sight to behold! If you submit a game, we'll play it a few times and give it a fair shake. Just be aware this process will take some time. We never commit to play testing a game within a fixed time frame.
2. Submitting a game does not guarantee an award.
All editorial decisions about what games receive reviews/awards are made in-house and are not influenced by publishers
We want The Spiel to remain a trusted source for objective independent reviews/awards.
This remains true as long as players and publishers trust that the games we review are being selected by us and not because of some back room deal. Our reviews cease to be of value or interest to anyone the minute we let publishers program the show. There are never fees or favors paid for any award or review we publish.
Given the thousands of titles being published, independent reviews and awards like The Spiel of Approval are essential to the game industry both for publishers and players.
For players, we provide a way to make informed decisions about games on the market.
For publishers, receiving a Spiel of Approval is a seal of quality (and a marketing coup) that few games receive.
We enjoy a wide range of games, from kids and party games all the way up the scale to heavy strategy games. You are welcome to submit a game for consideration for either the Major Fun or Spiel of Approval award.
Our focus is on board and card games; we don’t often venture into miniatures, collectible or role playing games. Browse our back catalog of episodes and you’ll see we cover a wide swathe of the game playing world.
I encourage you to contact me (firstname.lastname@example.org) if you have any questions about whether you think your game is a good fit for one of our awards.
If you’re a publisher and all of the above is acceptable to you, feel free to send 2 review copies** to:
1721 Marian Dr.
Indianapolis, IN 46240
**Because our team of play testers is located in several different places around the country, we ask that you submit two copies of a game whenever possible so more members of our team can participate in the play testing process.
We know how much time and effort and passion goes into every game. Please know that your work is deeply appreciated, and if you decide to submit your game, we are thankful you chose to share it with us.
We do not consider yet-to-be-published Kickstarter games. If you are looking for publicity for a Kickstarter campaign, check out our sponsorship page